I hear ya, I’m mostly interested to get info on these points (with scenarios) :
* Are the GM’s allowed to talk directly to the player? or do the agents tell their clients to not take any organization calls? Could a GM call a player directly and speak to him with no BS specifics like “This is more money then you’ll ever be able to spend in your/your kids lifetime” vs the agent whispering sweet nothings in his client’s ears (with the ultimate goal of getting the biggest commission check he can out of it)
* Do other teammates either freely or maybe asked by the GM to talk to the player about taking a team friendly deal? Are their official rules around this or mostly just an ethics call by the teammate to stay out of it? Do teammates ever call the player and put slight pressure on him to take a team friendly deal to keep the core together to win a cup?
* Does the NHLPA get involved at all if the player says “F#@$ it” and wants to accept a very undermarket offer to stay in in the city he’s been in and not uproot his family? What if Sydney Crosby wants to sign a 4 year extension with the Penguins at $1 million per, does the NHLPA step in and tell him he can’t do that because it will effect the contracts of future player deals?
Best bet is to post these questions to a Russo mailbag. Remember you’re posting on a fishing forum, so pretty sure no one here can definitively answer your questions. I have my ideas, but obviously can’t confirm them.
1-Nothing legally says a GM can’t contact (under contract) a player during negotiations. However, the agent probably makes it clear that player wants any communication to through the agent. So if the GM contacts the player directly with a tough love message, well they run a big risk of turning things sour between the player and the team. Becomes more of a trust/communication issue that could snowball into a big problem.
2-Teammates talk, lots of them are friends off the ice. I think you’d have more players telling each other to get all the money/term they can, rather than telling each other to take discounts for the organization. But overall it sure seems like they stay out of each others contract talks. The only thing you really see is when they congratulate each other on social media after a deal is signed.
3-Only example I can think of is there were rumors that the NHLPA was very unhappy when Kevin Labanc signed his 1x$1m deal a couple summer ago, when he could have easily got 3x the money and term. They didn’t say anything publicly but the talk was that they definitely did not approve of the contract and the precedent it set.