Don,
See if you can find any numbers stamped on the prop, I suspect what’s on there now has too much pitch.
For reference, my 1650 Rebel XL (tiller) with a 60 ran best with a 13″ prop, my slightly smaller/lighter 1650 Angler (tiller) with a 50 seems happy with a 12″ pitch 4-blade SpitFire.
HRG